You slipped on a wet store floor, tripped on a broken sidewalk, or fell on subway stairs. Now one word keeps coming up: "notice." In a New York City slip and fall (premises liability) case, it means two completely different things, and confusing them can mean a missed deadline.
Two kinds of notice
- Notice of the hazard (before you fall). Did the owner know, or should it have known, about the dangerous condition?
- The Notice of Claim (after you fall). A written, sworn document you must serve on (formally deliver to) most government defendants, such as the City or the MTA, within 90 days. It is a deadline, not a question of what the owner knew.
Notice of the hazard: actual vs. constructive notice
Owners and occupiers must keep their property reasonably safe under the circumstances. To hold one responsible, you must show that a dangerous or defective condition existed, and that the defendant either created it, or had actual or constructive notice of it and failed to fix it within a reasonable time.
- Actual notice: the owner or its employees actually knew. Examples: a prior complaint, an incident report, or an employee who saw the spill.
- Constructive notice: the owner should have known. The defect must be visible and apparent, and it must have existed long enough before the accident for the defendant's employees to discover and remedy it. A general awareness that a hazard might exist is not enough (Gordon v. American Museum of Natural History, 67 N.Y.2d 836 (1986)).
Evidence that helps show how long a hazard was there:
- dirty or tracked-through spills, footprints, dried edges
- photos taken right after the fall
- cleaning and inspection logs, and surveillance video
- witness statements and prior complaints
Your own share of fault, such as not watching where you were going, reduces but does not bar your recovery in a case like this (CPLR § 1411(a)).
Who is responsible for a New York City sidewalk?
It depends on the property next to it. NYC Administrative Code § 7-210 makes the owner of the abutting (bordering) property responsible for keeping the sidewalk reasonably safe, including repairing defective sidewalk flags (slabs) and removing snow and ice. That owner is liable for injuries caused by failing to do so.
The exception: one-, two- or three-family residential properties that are owner-occupied in whole or in part and used exclusively for residential purposes. For sidewalks in front of those homes, the City generally remains the responsible party.
NYC Administrative Code § 16-123 generally gives owners four hours after the snow stops falling to clear the sidewalk, not counting the hours between 9:00 p.m. and 7:00 a.m.
A tree well is not part of the "sidewalk" under § 7-210 (Vucetovic v. Epsom Downs, Inc., 10 N.Y.3d 517 (2008)).
Suing the City: prior written notice
Under NYC Administrative Code § 7-201(c)(2), the "Pothole Law," the City generally cannot be held liable for a defective street, sidewalk or crosswalk unless it received prior written notice of that specific defect (or there is a written acknowledgment from the City) and then failed to repair it within 15 days.
Courts recognize two exceptions to a prior-written-notice law (Amabile v. City of Buffalo, 93 N.Y.2d 471 (1999)): the City affirmatively created the defect through its own negligence, or a special use of the location conferred a special benefit on the City.
Prior written notice is still the first kind of notice: what the City knew before you fell. It is not the Notice of Claim you file afterward.
The Notice of Claim: New York's 90-day deadline
Under General Municipal Law § 50-e, before suing the City of New York (or most other public entities) over an injury like this, you must serve a written, sworn Notice of Claim within 90 days after the claim arises.
It must state your name and address (and your attorney's, if you have one), the nature of the claim, when, where and how it arose, and the injuries or damages claimed so far as then practicable. For claims against the City, it is filed with the Office of the NYC Comptroller, which accepts electronic filing.
The lawsuit must be started within one year and 90 days of the incident (General Municipal Law § 50-i).
If you miss the 90 days, General Municipal Law § 50-e(5) lets a court, in its discretion, extend the time to serve, but not beyond the one-year-and-90-day deadline to sue. It is never something to count on.
Subways, NYCHA, State property and private owners
- Subways and buses: claims against the New York City Transit Authority (subways and many City buses) and the MTA itself require a Notice of Claim within 90 days and a lawsuit within one year and 90 days (Public Authorities Law §§ 1212 and 1276). MTA subsidiaries are exempt from the formal Notice of Claim, but not from the deadline to sue (§ 1276(6)). It is not always obvious which agency runs a route, so treat 90 days as the deadline.
- NYCHA public housing: also a 90-day Notice of Claim and one year and 90 days to sue (Public Housing Law § 157).
- State of New York property: a different court and rule. A claim, or a written notice of intention to file one, must generally be served within 90 days (Court of Claims Act § 10(3)).
- Private owners (stores, landlords, restaurants): no Notice of Claim. The general three-year negligence deadline applies (CPLR § 214(5)).
What to do after a fall
- Photograph the exact condition and the surrounding area before it is cleaned or repaired, with something for scale.
- Report the fall, ask for an incident report, and get names of employees and witnesses.
- Note the exact address and location, and identify who owns the abutting property.
- Keep the shoes and clothing you were wearing, and get medical care promptly.
- If any government entity might be involved, treat the 90 days as the real deadline.
The bottom line
Notice of the hazard is what the owner knew, or should have known, before you fell. The Notice of Claim is what you serve on most government defendants afterward, within 90 days. A claim against the City or the MTA can involve both.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Deadlines turn on specific facts, so speak with a licensed New York attorney about your own situation. You can also start with the free AI intake assistant on our home page.